Explore the full pizza menu at Papa Joe's Pizza in Whitehall, Columbus, OH, available for convenient pickup any time you're craving a great pie.
Order online1-Item Pizza
$8.99+
Pizza with one chosen topping, real cheese, sauce, and special seasoning.
“Been eating this pizza for a long time and it taste rlly rlly good”
Chicago Style Pizza
$15.49
Pizza with cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, and onions.
“Great pizza!!”
Spicy Joe Pizza
$15.49
Pizza with pepperoni, bacon, sausage, jalapeños, and crushed red peppers.
“Great pizza give it a try guarantee you won't be disappointed.”
Papa Joe's Pizza in Whitehall, Columbus, OH serves a wide pizza selection, from classic one-topping pies to loaded specialty options built for every craving and group size.
Standout choices include the Beef House Pizza, Meat Lovers Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Gyro Pizza, Spicy Joe Pizza, and the shareable Monster Pizza with One Topping.
Visit Papa Joe's Pizza in Whitehall, Columbus, OH to dine-in with friends, or place an order for pickup or delivery whenever a pizza craving strikes.
Beef House Pizza
$15.99+
Beef House Pizza has cheese, beef pepperoni, peppers, and ground beef.
“Damn good pizza, fresh, hot and so good I ate almost the whole small meat pizza myself, worth every cent! And leftovers for later! Mine was the beef house pizza,minus the green 🫑, banana peppers instead, my perfect pizza 🤤”
Beef Pepperoni Pizza
$9.99+
Pizza topped with beef pepperoni, real cheese, sauce, and seasoning.
“Really good pizza, even good as leftovers.”
Hawaiian Pizza
$15.49
A pizza topped with real cheese, ham, pineapple, and bacon.
“Great fresh and delicious pizza! Great staff. Great local option.”
Large One Topping Pizza, 8 Pieces Wings & 2 Liter Pop Wednesday Special
$24.99
A large one-topping pizza served with eight wings and soda.
“This is the best local delivery pizza in the area. Pizza is always delivered hot, unlike the chain stores they still have their own delivery drivers amd dont use doordash. The pizza is delicious and better then what you will get at pizza hut or papa johns. I 10/10 recommend Papa Joes”
14'' Large One Topping Pizza & Two Rich Boy Subs Friday Special
$26.99
A 14-inch pizza with one chosen topping comes with two classic Rich Boy subs.
16'' X-Large One Topping Pizza Sunday Special
$14.99
16-inch pizza with one chosen topping, cheese, and special sauce.
16'' X-Large One Topping Pizza Thursday Special
$14.99
16-inch extra-large pizza with one topping, cheese, and special sauce.
BBQ Chicken Pizza
$15.49
Pizza topped with cheese, chicken, onions, bacon, and BBQ sauce.
BLT Pizza
$15.49
Bacon pizza with sauce and cheese, topped with mayo, lettuce, and tomato.
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
$15.49
Pizza with chicken, onions, banana peppers, cheese, and Buffalo sauce.
Family Special
$34.99
Family Special includes two large one-topping pizzas and two subs.
Gyro Pizza
$15.49
Pizza with gyro meat, cheese, onions, peppers, ranch, lettuce, and tomato.
House Pizza
$14.49+
Pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms, banana peppers, onions, and ground beef.
Meat Lovers Pizza
$15.49+
Pizza topped with cheese, pepperoni, beef, ham, sausage, and bacon.
Medium One Topping Pizza Tuesday Special
$10.99
A 12-inch pizza with real cheese, special sauce, and one topping.
Monster Pizza with One Topping
$37.99
A two-foot pizza with real cheese and your required topping choice.
One Topping Pizza
$8.99+
Pizza with one selected topping, real cheese, sauce, and special seasoning.
Two 12'' Medium One Topping Pizzas Saturday Special
$19.99
Two medium 12-inch pizzas each include one chosen topping.
Two One Topping Pizza Special
$19.99+
Two pizzas with real cheese, special sauce, and one chosen topping each.
Vegetarian Pizza
$14.49+
Vegetarian pizza with cheese, mushrooms, peppers, tomatoes, and onions.
14'' Large One Topping Pizza Monday Special
$12.99
A 14-inch pizza with real cheese, special sauce, and one required topping.
“After passing this place by for years, I finally decided to try it and find out. Pleasantly surprised at how good this pizza is. I'm old enough to remember that there were quite few of the Papa Joe's around yesrs ago. But they faded out. So glad that this one managed to stay around. We all have different preferences when it comes to what we like in a pizza. I'm quite selective. I Really like this pizza.....Good pizza!”
Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.
