Family Special
$34.99
Two large one-topping pizzas are served with two Rich Boy subs.
Italian Food in Whitehall, Columbus
One-topping pizzas and lasagna anchor Italian food at Papa Joe's Pizza in Whitehall, Columbus, OH, with pickup available for your meal.
Order online
A Taste of Papa Joe's Pizza
Papa Joe's Pizza serves Italian food with one-topping pizzas, meat-and-vegetable combinations, lasagna, salads, and garlic bread. You'll find pizzas with BBQ sauce alongside others with special seasoning.
Hawaiian Pizza pairs ham, pineapple, and bacon with real cheese. Buffalo Chicken Pizza has onions, banana peppers, and Buffalo sauce. Chicago Style Pizza combines pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, and onions.
Order in Whitehall, Columbus, OH for pickup, dine-in, or delivery. Meat Lasagna comes with a small salad and garlic bread; Antipasto Salad includes salami and pepperoni, with Italian or ranch dressing.
Italian Food to Try
1-Item Pizza
A one-topping pizza with real cheese, sauce, and special seasoning.
- Medium Pepperoni Pizza$11.99Medium pizza with pepperoni as its selected topping, plus real cheese, sauce, and Papa Joe’s special seasoning.
- Large Pepperoni Pizza$14.99Large pizza with pepperoni as its selected topping, plus real cheese, sauce, and Papa Joe’s special seasoning.
- X-Large Extra Cheese Pizza$16.99X-large pizza with extra cheese as its selected topping, sauce, and Papa Joe’s special seasoning.
- X-Large Pepperoni Pizza$16.99X-large pizza with pepperoni as its selected topping, plus real cheese, sauce, and Papa Joe’s special seasoning.
- Small Pepperoni Pizza$8.99Small pizza with pepperoni as its selected topping, plus real cheese, sauce, and Papa Joe’s special seasoning.
- Medium Extra Cheese Pizza$11.99Medium pizza with extra cheese as its selected topping, sauce, and Papa Joe’s special seasoning.
14'' Large One Topping Pizza & Two Rich Boy Subs Friday Special
A 14-inch one-topping pizza comes with two classic Rich Boy subs.
- Pepperoni and Onion Pizza with Two Rich Boy Subs$29.24A 14-inch pizza with pepperoni and onions, served with two classic Rich Boy subs in the Friday special.
- Cheese Pizza with Two Rich Boy Subs$26.99A 14-inch cheese pizza served with two classic Rich Boy subs in the Friday special.
- Sausage Pizza with Two Rich Boy Subs$26.99A 14-inch sausage pizza served with two classic Rich Boy subs in the Friday special.
- Bacon Pizza with Two Rich Boy Subs$26.99A 14-inch bacon pizza served with two classic Rich Boy subs in the Friday special.
- Mushroom Pizza with Two Rich Boy Subs$26.99A 14-inch mushroom pizza served with two classic Rich Boy subs in the Friday special.
16'' X-Large One Topping Pizza Sunday Special
A 16-inch one-topping pizza with real cheese and special sauce.
- 16-Inch Beef Pepperoni and Cheese Pizza$17.49Made with Papa Joe's special sauce, real cheese, and beef pepperoni on a 16-inch extra-large crust.
- 16-Inch Pepperoni Pizza$14.99A 16-inch extra-large pizza with Papa Joe's special sauce, real cheese, and pepperoni.
- 16-Inch Sausage Pizza$14.99A 16-inch extra-large pizza with Papa Joe's special sauce, real cheese, and sausage.
- 16-Inch Mushroom Pizza$14.99A 16-inch extra-large pizza with Papa Joe's special sauce, real cheese, and mushrooms.
- 16-Inch Green Pepper Pizza$14.99A 16-inch extra-large pizza with Papa Joe's special sauce, real cheese, and green peppers.
- 16-Inch Bacon Pizza$14.99A 16-inch extra-large pizza with Papa Joe's special sauce, real cheese, and bacon.
16'' X-Large One Topping Pizza Thursday Special
A 16-inch one-topping pizza with real cheese and special sauce.
- 16-Inch Pepperoni Pizza$14.9916-inch extra-large pizza with real cheese, Papa Joe's special sauce, and pepperoni as its selected topping.
- 16-Inch Cheese Pizza$14.9916-inch extra-large pizza with real cheese and Papa Joe's special sauce, without an additional topping.
- 16-Inch Sausage Pizza$14.9916-inch extra-large pizza with real cheese, Papa Joe's special sauce, and sausage as its selected topping.
- 16-Inch Bacon Pizza$14.9916-inch extra-large pizza with real cheese, Papa Joe's special sauce, and bacon as its selected topping.
- 16-Inch Mushroom Pizza$14.9916-inch extra-large pizza with real cheese, Papa Joe's special sauce, and mushrooms as its selected topping.
- 16-Inch Beef Pepperoni Pizza$17.4916-inch extra-large cheese pizza with Papa Joe's special sauce and beef pepperoni added as a topping.
Large One Topping Pizza, 8 Pieces Wings & 2 Liter Pop Wednesday Special
A large pizza, eight wings, and two liters of pop make this Wednesday deal.
- Pepperoni Pizza & BBQ Wings Wednesday Special$24.99Large pepperoni pizza with eight BBQ wings and a 2-liter Pepsi.
- Cheese Pizza & Garlic Parmesan Wings Wednesday Special$24.99Large cheese pizza with eight garlic Parmesan wings and a 2-liter Pepsi.
- Sausage Pizza & Mild Buffalo Wings Wednesday Special$24.99Large sausage pizza with eight mild Buffalo wings and a 2-liter Pepsi.
- Bacon Pizza & Hot Wings Wednesday Special$24.99Large bacon pizza with eight hot wings and a 2-liter Pepsi.
- Chicken Pizza & Teriyaki Wings Wednesday Special$24.99Large chicken pizza with eight teriyaki wings and a 2-liter Pepsi.
- Mushroom Pizza & Plain Wings Wednesday Special$24.99Large mushroom pizza with eight plain wings and a 2-liter Pepsi.
Medium One Topping Pizza Tuesday Special
A 12-inch pizza with one chosen topping, real cheese, and special sauce.
- Medium Pepperoni Pizza$10.99A 12-inch medium pizza topped with pepperoni, real cheese, and Papa Joe's special sauce.
- Medium Sausage Pizza$10.99A 12-inch medium pizza topped with sausage, real cheese, and Papa Joe's special sauce.
- Medium Bacon Pizza$10.99A 12-inch medium pizza topped with bacon, real cheese, and Papa Joe's special sauce.
- Medium Mushroom Pizza$10.99A 12-inch medium pizza topped with mushrooms, real cheese, and Papa Joe's special sauce.
- Medium Chicken Pizza$10.99A 12-inch medium pizza topped with chicken, real cheese, and Papa Joe's special sauce.
Monster Pizza with One Topping
This two-foot pizza comes with real cheese and your choice of one topping.
- 2-Foot Pepperoni Pizza$37.99A 2-foot monster pizza topped with pepperoni, real cheese, and Papa Joe's special seasoning.
- 2-Foot Beef Pepperoni Pizza$37.99A 2-foot monster pizza topped with beef pepperoni, real cheese, and Papa Joe's special seasoning.
- 2-Foot Bacon Pizza$37.99A 2-foot monster pizza topped with bacon, real cheese, and Papa Joe's special seasoning.
- 2-Foot Sausage Pizza$37.99A 2-foot monster pizza topped with sausage, real cheese, and Papa Joe's special seasoning.
- 2-Foot Mushroom Pizza$37.99A 2-foot monster pizza topped with mushrooms, real cheese, and Papa Joe's special seasoning.
- 2-Foot Cheese Pizza$37.99A 2-foot monster cheese pizza made with real cheese and Papa Joe's special seasoning.
One Topping Pizza
A pizza with your chosen topping, real cheese, sauce, and seasoning.
- Small Pepperoni Pizza$8.99A 10-inch pizza topped with pepperoni, real cheese, sauce, and Papa Joe's special seasoning.
- Large Pepperoni Pizza$14.99A 14-inch pizza topped with pepperoni, real cheese, sauce, and Papa Joe's special seasoning.
- Large Pepperoni, Sausage & Extra Cheese Pizza$18.49A 14-inch pizza with pepperoni, sausage, extra cheese, sauce, and Papa Joe's special seasoning.
- Large Pineapple Pizza$14.99A 14-inch pizza topped with pineapple, real cheese, sauce, and Papa Joe's special seasoning.
- X-Large Sausage & Green Pepper Pizza$20.49A 16-inch cheese pizza with sausage and green peppers, sauce, and Papa Joe's special seasoning.
- Medium Cheese Pizza$11.99A 12-inch cheese pizza with real cheese, sauce, and Papa Joe's special seasoning.
Two 12'' Medium One Topping Pizzas Saturday Special
Two 12-inch pizzas, each with one topping of your choice.
- Pepperoni, Sausage, Chicken & Pineapple Pizza Pair$23.99One 12-inch medium pizza has pepperoni and sausage; the other has chicken and pineapple.
- Three-Pepperoni Two-Pizza Special$21.99One 12-inch medium pizza has pepperoni with extra pepperoni, and the other has pepperoni.
- Pepperoni & Sausage Two-Pizza Special$19.99Two 12-inch medium pizzas feature pepperoni on one and sausage on the other.
- Cheese & Pepperoni Two-Pizza Special$19.99Two 12-inch medium pizzas include one cheese pizza and one topped with pepperoni.
- Mushroom & Green Pepper Two-Pizza Special$19.99Two 12-inch medium pizzas feature mushrooms on one and green peppers on the other.
Two One Topping Pizza Special
Two pizzas with one topping each, real cheese, and Papa Joe's sauce.
- Two Medium Pepperoni Pizzas$19.99Two medium pizzas with one pepperoni topping on each, made with real cheese and Papa Joe's special sauce.
- Two Large Pepperoni Pizzas$27.99Two large pizzas with one pepperoni topping on each, made with real cheese and Papa Joe's special sauce.
- Two Medium Pepperoni and Cheese Pizzas$19.99One medium pepperoni pizza and one medium cheese pizza, made with real cheese and Papa Joe's special sauce.
- Two Large Cheese and Beef Pepperoni Pizzas$29.99Two large cheese pizzas, with beef pepperoni added to one, made with real cheese and Papa Joe's special sauce.
- Two Large Pepperoni and Cheese Pizzas$27.99One large pepperoni pizza and one large cheese pizza, made with real cheese and Papa Joe's special sauce.
- Two Medium Sausage and Pepperoni Pizzas$19.99One medium sausage pizza and one medium pepperoni pizza, made with real cheese and Papa Joe's special sauce.
14'' Large One Topping Pizza Monday Special
A 14-inch pizza with real cheese, special sauce, and one topping.
- 14-Inch Pepperoni Pizza$12.9914-inch pizza topped with pepperoni, real cheese, and Papa Joe's special sauce.
- 14-Inch Beef Pepperoni & Extra Cheese Pizza$15.2414-inch pizza with beef pepperoni, extra cheese, and Papa Joe's special sauce.
- 14-Inch Sausage Pizza$12.9914-inch pizza topped with sausage, real cheese, and Papa Joe's special sauce.
- 14-Inch Bacon Pizza$12.9914-inch pizza topped with bacon, real cheese, and Papa Joe's special sauce.
- 14-Inch Mushroom Pizza$12.9914-inch pizza topped with mushrooms, real cheese, and Papa Joe's special sauce.
- 14-Inch Green Pepper Pizza$12.9914-inch pizza topped with green peppers, real cheese, and Papa Joe's special sauce.
Beef House Pizza
$15.99+
Beef pepperoni, ground beef, and vegetables top this cheesy pizza.
“Damn good pizza, fresh, hot and so good I ate almost the whole small meat pizza myself, worth every cent! And leftovers for later! Mine was the beef house pizza,minus the green 🫑, banana peppers instead, my perfect pizza 🤤”
Antipasto Salad
$9.99
Lettuce, meats, peppers, mushrooms, tomatoes, and cheese make this salad.
BBQ Chicken Pizza
$15.49
Chicken, bacon, onions, real cheese, and BBQ sauce top this pizza.
BLT Pizza
$15.49
Bacon and cheese bake on pizza, finished with lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
$15.49
Chicken, onions, banana peppers, cheese, and buffalo sauce top this pizza.
Chicago Style Pizza
$15.49
Real cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, and onions top this pizza.
Garlic Bread
$2.99
Freshly baked bread is brushed with garlic butter and toasted.
Garlic Bread with Cheese
$4.99
Toasted garlic bread topped with melted mozzarella cheese.
Gyro Pizza
$15.49
Gyro meat, onions, banana peppers, and ranch top this pizza.
Hawaiian Pizza
$15.49
Pizza topped with real cheese, ham, pineapple, and bacon.
Meat Lasagna
$9.99
Meat lasagna comes with a small salad and garlic bread.
Meat Lovers Pizza
$15.49+
Pepperoni, beef, ham, sausage, and bacon top this cheesy pizza.
Spicy Joe Pizza
$15.49
Pepperoni, bacon, sausage, and hot peppers top this cheesy pizza.
Vegetarian Pizza
$14.49+
Vegetarian pizza with cheese, mushrooms, tomatoes, onions, and peppers.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are your most popular Italian food options?
Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.
- 1-Item Pizza — Choose a size and one topping for this pizza, made with real cheese, sauce, and Papa Joe's special seasoning.
- Family Special — This family bundle includes two large pizzas with one topping each and two Rich Boy subs for sharing.
- House Pizza — Real cheese, pepperoni, ground beef, mushrooms, banana peppers, green peppers, and onions are included; beef pepperoni substitution is optional.
- Beef Pepperoni Pizza — Choose a size for this pizza topped with beef pepperoni, real cheese, sauce, and Papa Joe's special seasoning.
- Monster Pizza with One Topping — The two-foot pizza includes real cheese and one required topping choice, with extra toppings available to add.
Do you offer delivery and takeout?
Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for italian food throughout the Whitehall, Columbus area. Order your italian food online for convenient pickup or delivery.
